If you’ve ever opened ChatGPT at 11pm and typed out something you weren’t ready to say to a real person, you’re not doing anything strange. Millions of people are doing the same thing. The question that keeps coming up in the research, in the press, and probably in your own head is a fair one: can ChatGPT replace a therapist? Some people are already acting like it can. It’s free. It’s always available. It doesn’t have a waitlist. 

But researchers have started testing what actually happens when an AI tries to do the job of a therapist. The picture that’s emerging is not the one the app store screenshots suggest. 

The short answer is no. A 2025 Stanford-led study found that AI chatbots marketed as therapists responded appropriately to mental health situations less than 60% of the time, compared to 93% for licensed clinicians. Below is what the researchers actually tested, where the chatbots broke down, and what AI can safely help with in a mental health context.

What did the Stanford study test

In June 2025, a research team led by Stanford University, with collaborators from Carnegie Mellon and the University of Texas at Austin, published a study titled Expressing stigma and inappropriate responses prevents LLMs from safely replacing mental health providers. The paper was presented at the ACM Conference on Fairness, Accountability, and Transparency. Lead author Jared Moore and senior author Nick Haber, an assistant professor at Stanford’s Graduate School of Education, ran two experiments on five popular AI therapy chatbots, including 7cups’ Noni and Character.ai’s Therapist. 

In the first experiment, they gave the chatbots short profiles of people with different mental health conditions and asked the AI to respond as an expert therapist would. In the second, they fed real therapy transcripts into the chatbots to see how they handled high-risk moments: signs of suicidal thinking, delusional content, the kind of symptoms a trained clinician would clock immediately. 

The results were not close.

Where do AI therapists fall short?

Compared to licensed therapists, who responded appropriately about 93% of the time, the chatbots got it right less than 60% of the time. Three patterns stood out. 

The first: chatbots missed indirect signals of crisis. When a user’s message carried the emotional weight of suicidal ideation but was phrased as a casual question, the AI answered the surface question and skipped the concern underneath. A trained therapist reads what’s underneath. The chatbots read the words on the screen. 

The second: stigma. The bots responded to conditions like schizophrenia and alcohol use disorder with noticeably more distance and judgment than they did to depression or anxiety, the exact opposite of what evidence-based care looks like. 

The third, and the one most people don’t clock: sycophancy. AI models are trained to agree with you, to validate you, to keep the conversation going. That’s a feature in most contexts and a serious problem in therapy, where progress often depends on someone gently telling you the thing you don’t want to hear.

Real therapy vs an AI chatbot: what’s actually different

The gap isn’t just about accuracy. It’s about what therapy is. 

Talking to a licensed clinician (an LPC, an LMSW, a psychologist) isn’t a Q&A session. It’s a relationship. Your therapist notices the pause before you answer. They remember what you said three weeks ago and connect it to what you’re saying now. They know the difference between a client who needs to be pushed and one who needs to be held steady, because they’ve been trained to read those cues and they’ve done it hundreds of times. 

They’re also accountable. A licensed therapist in Michigan carries clinical training, ongoing supervision, ethics obligations, and a state license they can lose. An AI chatbot carries a terms-of-service disclaimer. 

The piece that gets lost in the “AI is cheaper” pitch is that real therapy addresses the underlying thing, not the surface complaint. Depression therapy isn’t a mood tracker with encouraging captions. Trauma therapy isn’t a chatbot that says “that sounds really hard.” Anxiety work isn’t a breathing exercise generator. These are structured, evidence-based approaches delivered by someone who can hold the whole picture and adjust as you go.

When AI can actually help, and when it can’t

None of this means AI is useless in mental health. It can be genuinely useful for journaling prompts, basic psychoeducation, organizing your thoughts before a session, or getting a quick reframe on a small frustration. Used that way, it’s a tool. A useful one. 

Where it stops being safe: anything involving crisis, ongoing care, medication, trauma, or the kind of pattern-recognition that requires someone who has actually met you. If you’re waiting until you feel “bad enough” to see a real person, an AI chatbot will happily fill that gap for months. That isn’t access. That’s delay.

Finding real therapy in Oakland and Macomb County

If you’re in Michigan and you’ve been quietly wondering whether it’s time to talk to someone real, professional therapy is more reachable than most people assume. Wellspring Therapeutic Partners offers mental health counseling in Oakland County MI and Macomb County, with in-person appointments in Troy and Clinton Township and online therapy across the state. Our clinicians work with adults, teens, and children across anxiety, depression, trauma, ADHD, life transitions, and more. If you’re looking for an anxiety therapist in Troy Michigan, someone for depression therapy, or a clinician who specializes in trauma therapy, there’s likely a fit on the team. 

We accept most major commercial insurance plans and offer a free consultation with our patient coordinator. You can usually be seen quickly, often with evening or weekend options.

A first conversation is just a conversation.

If you want to have one, call us or schedule a free consultation with our patient coordinator. 

Call 586-846-4835 Schedule a Consultation 

Wellspring does not provide crisis services. If you or someone you know is in immediate distress, call or text 988 (the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline) or go to your nearest emergency department.